Andrés Giménez is a 27-year-old, left-handed hitting, middle infielder.
The Jays picked him up in trade from the Guardians in early December 2024, along with Nick Sandlin for Spencer Horwitz and minor leaguer Nick Mitchell. Horwitz was quickly flipped to the Pirates.
Advertisement
Horwitz hit .272/.353/.434 with 11 home runs for Pittsburgh, playing first base with a 1.6 bWAR. Not bad.
Mitchell played 85 games across three levels (rookie, A, A+) hitting .273/.386/.370 with 30 steals. FanGraphs has him #36 on their top 46 Guardian prospects.
Giménez hit .210/.285/.313 with 7 home runs (3 of them came in our first 5 games), for a 1.1 bWAR in 101 games. He was slowed by injuries, missing 23 games due to quad tightness and 31 due to an ankle sprain. It was his first time on the IL since 2020, when he was a Met. Unfortunately, the injuries slowed him when he came off the IL.
The bat wasn’t great, but the defence, on the other hand, was great. FanGraphs has him at 10 Outs Above Average (second best in the majors) at second base, which is amazing considering he only played about half a season worth of games at the position.
Advertisement
The first few games, when the team decided, against all logic, to have Giménez cleanup, were surreal, especially when he homered in the first game (and third and fifth). Of course, after those first five games, he hit .169/.247/.200 in the cleanup spot. Using him in that spot was the most puzzling lineup decision of the season (and there were several puzzling lineup choices).
This year, he’s going to be a shortstop. I guess there is a question of whether he’ll be as good at short as he is at second. We watched him play short in the playoffs, and he looked good there to me. He has plenty of arm, generally middle infielders play second because they don’t have the arm for short, but Giménez doesn’t seem to have any issues there. I think he has a good shot at being a Gold Glover at short.
The other question is, ‘Will he hit any better next year?’ That one I can’t answer, though I’d like to think that, without the leg and ankle injuries, he’d have to hit better. And he’d likely steal more bases (he had 12 steals last year, 30 in each of the two previous seasons).
The real answer is ‘He couldn’t hit much worse than last year.‘
Advertisement
Andrés hit much better vs. RHP (.221/.301/.329) than against LHP (.175/.233/.263). We platooned him some at second base; I doubt he’ll be platooned much at short.
Steamer thinks he’ll play in 134 games this year, hitting .253/.311/.384 with 12 home runs and 18 steals. Yeah, that won’t make us forget Bo, but then I’m hoping he’ll make up for it on defense.
