The Penguins find themselves in an interesting and surprising position coming out of the Olympic break. They’ve banked 70 points in the standings after 56 games and are firmly in the hunt for a playoff position, currently sitting fourth in the Eastern Conference in points percentage. Perhaps more importantly, the Pens are second in the Metropolitan Division. To the world, it looks like a four-team race between Pittsburgh, the Islanders, Columbus and Washington for the two guaranteed playoff spots in the Metropolitan, with perhaps a chance for the third team to earn a Wild Card playoff spot if the Atlantic Division teams in the mix like Buffalo or Boston slow down a bit.
As such, the Penguins are in a solid spot, yet not one where they’re likely to steer away from their overall plan to prioritize the future. The team has already made some moves to improve the team, bringing in Egor Chinakhov and Brett Kulak (plus Stuart Skinner) has worked out well. Amazingly, the overall net of those transactions amounts to one third round pick plus Tristan Jarry leaving the organization. That’s probably the type of moves that will be considered in the future, GM Kyle Dubas has a glut of future draft picks to work with but won’t be in a hurry to bring in older players on expiring deals that will only have a short-term impact on the team.
Advertisement
That desire has to also be weighed against the areas for opportunity to improve. Chinakhov’s addition has really solidified the depth and talent level of the forward group to the point where the cost of improvements might not be worth disrupting the chemistry or pushing out players who have put Pittsburgh in the current position in the first place. Same thought applies in net, where changes have been addressed by swapping Skinner for Jarry.
This leaves the blueline as a key area to monitor, where the Pens could dip their toes in the trade waters to seek an upgrade and add more quality depth to their group. The Athletic paired together some teams and likely tradeable players, while Pittsburgh wasn’t highlighted there was some utility in seeing what some proposed prices could be and where the Pens might try to insert themselves in negotiations.
Detroit Red Wings
The perfect fit: Justin Faulk, RHD, St. Louis Blues
The trade: Faulk for Detroit’s 2026 first-round pick, 2028 second-round pick, LHD prospect William Wallinder and G prospect Landon Miller
We start out with a doozy. Justin Faulk is an impending free agent and projects to have a huge price based on this. The Pittsburgh equivalent might mean including Owen Pickering and Joel Blomqvist as the prospects involved, to go along with a first and second round draft pick. If something like that ends up being the price, it’s extremely difficult to see the Pens as being terrible interested in shopping down this aisle. Faulk is a quality player, but he plays the right side and has played big minutes on the power play. That’s not a great fit for a team that already has Erik Karlsson and Kris Letang for that role.
Buffalo Sabres
The perfect fit: Connor Murphy, RHD, Chicago Blackhawks
The trade: Murphy for the Sabres’ 2027 second-round pick
A player like Murphy could be more in tune for Pittsburgh’s needs. The 32-year old has great size (6’4”, 212 pounds) and plays more of a stay-at-home defensive type of game from the right side, adding excellent defensive impacts, though it may be concerning his even strength ice time and role with Chicago has been limited this season.
Advertisement
The price is one where the Pens could get into as well. Pittsburgh owns two picks in the second rounds in all of the 2026, 2027, 2028 and 2029 drafts. They have two third round picks in 2026, 2027 and 2028, positioning them exceptionally strongly for a potential trade like this. Murphy is also an impending free agent, Pittsburgh would have to think about if burning some of their excess was worth it, or even if they wanted to keep Murphy in the fold for the future with a contract extension.
Murphy isn’t a complete necessity but adding him to the group would make a lot of sense if that was the direction they wanted to go to attempt to shore things up defensively and add a veteran to the penalty kill.
Dallas Stars
The perfect fit: Zach Whitecloud, RHD, Calgary Flames
The trade: Whitecloud for the Stars’ 2026 second-round pick and 2027 fourth-round pick
Whitecloud has been a popular name on the ol’ wishlist for potential adds for the Pens and for very good reason. There’s a lot to like, at 29-years old he’s younger than many of the names in the rumor mill. Whitecloud also carries a reasonable $2.75 million cap hit for two seasons after this year. He’s got 78 career games of playoff experience and had a role in Vegas’s 2023 Stanley Cup win. That fits nicely in the mold of what the Penguins would want to do about acquiring players who would be more than a short-term add.
And again, the draft pick excess portions from the Murphy paragraph all dovetail in nicely here as well. The Pens are in a position to easily afford dropping a couple of mid-round picks for an NHL caliber defenseman if they are so inclined to do it, and this proposed price looks very reasonable.
Advertisement
You never know what teams are thinking (including Calgary, who needs some NHL caliber players of their own and might not feel urgency to move Whitecloud at this juncture) but this fit, price and situation all sounds like a very good match. That doesn’t guarantee a transaction will get made, but you’d have to think a lot of the variables align in this case.
Edmonton Oilers
The perfect fit: Bobby McMann, LW/RW, Toronto Maple Leafs
The trade: McMann for the Oilers’ 2026 second-round pick and RW prospect Tommy Lafrenière
We’ve been focusing on defensemen, yet one thing to remember about Dubas is that he often tends to zig when you might expect a zag. He also has a penchant for bringing in players that he is familiar with, to which Bobby McMann certainly fits as a Dubas/Wes Clark project they took on with Toronto in 2020 and watched grow into a very nice player.
Perhaps the Pens like someone like Justin Brazeau too much to acquire another player for a similar mid-line role. Perhaps McMann (who has scored 15 and 20 goals in the last two seasons, plus 19 in 56 games this year so far) has too high of a profile to justify burning futures on for what could be a short-term reunion. It would be easier to hold tight and do nothing.
But doing nothing hasn’t been Dubas’s M.O. He’s swapped players (even ones he likes like Conor Timmins) in and out of the team with frequency. Would it be shocking to see the Pens go so far as to send out Brazeau in a deal and use that return to partially or completely offset what it would take to acquire McMann? Or just grab McMann and make an already stocked forward group that much more loaded? It couldn’t or perhaps shouldn’t be too surprising, those are the types of moves Dubas has been making non-stop in the past couple of years to shuffle pieces of the board around in rapid succession while looking for incremental improvements.
Advertisement
The best bet for a realistic scenario might be to hold on or spend the time looking in other areas, but the one thing that Dubas has shown so far is a willingness to make unexpected moves out of the blue. His approach to the 2026 deadline will be instrumental in positioning the team down the stretch as they look to get back to the playoffs for the first time since 2022.
