The national media have been all over Mark Pope this offseason. You have some leaking information that other programs are cracking jokes about how Kentucky recruits. You have others openly questioning what the plan is. And now you have one saying the roster Mark Pope built may be one of the worst in the SEC.
With only two roster spots remaining as the calendar flips to May, Mark Pope’s latest roster rebuild is almost done. Following a brutal string of high-profile recruiting misses, including Tyran Stokes to Kansas, the Wildcats are staring down a roster that isn’t as talented as what Kentucky has grown accustomed to.
Advertisement
According to one prominent analyst, Kentucky isn’t just lacking star power; they are lagging behind almost the entire conference.
The “bottom 5” assessment
Aaron Gershon did not mince words when evaluating the current state of Pope’s program. In a scathing critique of the Wildcats’ offseason execution, Gershon painted a bleak picture of where Kentucky currently stands in the SEC hierarchy.
“Objectively, on paper, Kentucky has a bottom 5 roster in the SEC right now, and it’s about to be May,” Gershon stated.
He noted that the only way to salvage the offseason is for Pope to pull a massive rabbit out of his hat late in the game. “Is there time? Sure, stunners with some of the cuspy draft guys could be pulled off. But it’s going to take that, ‘stunners’ for this roster to be good enough.”
Advertisement
Those necessary “stunners” would likely have to be massive NBA Draft portal decisions. The two most likely right now seem to be Iowa State’s Milan Momcilovic or Wake Forest’s Juke Harris. Relying on the hope of a player in late May is a dangerous game to play.
Was the year 1 roster actually better?
When fans pushed back against Gershon’s harsh assessment by pointing out that Pope took a seemingly “worse” roster on paper to the Sweet 16 during his first year, the analyst aggressively doubled down.
“Disagree. That roster was better,” Gershon fired back, listing off the proven collegiate resumes of Pope’s inaugural portal class. “Lamont [Butler] was a proven PG with multiple DPOY awards and a F4, [Koby] Brea proven elite shooter, [Jaxson] Robinson was the BIG 12 6th MOY, Amari [Williams] 3X DPOY in CAA, [Andrew] Carr a double figures guy in ACC, etc.”
Advertisement
He hit the nail on the head regarding the current squad’s biggest flaw: “There’s less proven success on this team.”
That lack of proven success is the biggest issue. Some guys may take a step and really surprise, but few of them have shown the ability to do it at a really elite level.
The problem with being a surprise team
None of this means the season is already over, though if you read some articles and some posts, you may think it is. Basketball is played on hardwood, not on paper. The team could take the court, gel perfectly in Pope’s offensive system, and surprise everyone.
But therein lies the overarching problem.
Advertisement
This is the University of Kentucky. It is fundamentally unacceptable for the Wildcats to be entering a season hoping to “surprise” people with how good they are. When Kentucky surprises the country, it should be because they are blowing elite teams out by 20 points, not because they managed to scrape together a winning record with a roster of lesser-heralded players.
If Mark Pope’s program is reduced to playing the plucky underdog role because he can’t secure elite talent on the recruiting trail or in the portal, his tenure in Lexington is going to be incredibly short-lived.
